11 hours ago
8
My mother-in-law is still driving. After a near miss a few months ago, we told her she was no longer to drive with our children in her car, and we were grateful that she immediately agreed – but also puzzled that she didn’t consider stopping altogether.
A year ago she developed cataracts and was told to stop driving. She coped well, using her free bus pass and walking, which she doesn’t mind doing and knows is good for her health. However, when the cataract had been treated, the doctor told her she could drive again.
Recently, her car insurance was renewed, and she paid a hefty sum that we felt would have been better spent on taxis.
All her life my mother-in-law has been ‘useful’, and she is very proud that her four children have grown up to also be kind, helpful people. She continues to drive because it is useful, and she offers lifts to elderly friends which we fear is an accident waiting to happen. I love her dearly and would hate her to come to any harm.
We live slightly farther away than her other children, who help her the most with finances and some practical things. We realise that if she stopped driving she might need more help, which we don’t have the capacity to provide. However, we feel the risks to herself and the community outweigh any inconvenience to the wider family.
Please give us a script we can use to express ourselves in a new way. Her other children continue to be dismissive of our concerns, and I don’t know what to say to convince her that it’s her turn to be looked after and chauffeured about by others.
This has become an increasingly common problem. I remember some years ago, talking to psychotherapist Chris Mills about a friend’s mum who had dementia and was no longer safe to drive. He said something I never forgot: “If we were talking about a gun, no one would hesitate over taking it off her. Yet a car can also kill.” So I went to Mills again with your letter.
“Your request for a ‘script’ is the easy bit,” he said “as it doesn’t sound as if you’ve yet said to your mother-in-law words to the effect of, ‘We don’t believe your driving is safe any more, and we’d like you to give up your car now and use other ways of getting around, before someone gets hurt.’ It is absolutely your business to say this, because it is your own concerns that you’re reporting.”
Realising you are at the stage of life where you can no longer do things is a huge deal. So you’re right to tread carefully. I would stress how much you care about her and the help she is still able to give you.
“But,” continued Mills, “before going ahead with this, I’m not clear why you are taking this on, rather than your husband – why you have written this letter, not him. He is her son and his siblings’ brother. There is usually someone in the family who is the “canary” and sees things before others can. But might you run the risk of being cast as the over-fussy interfering in-law?”
after newsletter promotion
Mills suggests your husband could contact her GP to request a reassessment of her driving ability. “There’s no guarantee that your mother-in-law or your husband’s siblings will approve of any of this, but that shouldn’t prevent him from doing what he believes is the right thing – ie in the absence of his mother’s agreement, ensuring that the decision about her potentially dangerous driving is passed to the relevant authority.”
In England and Wales, the DVLA issues licences and can revoke them or ask for medical confirmation that someone is fit to drive. You can also report your concerns to the DVLA via their website.
Remember that this will be about so much more than just driving, so please reassure your mother-in-law about how much she is still needed.
Every week, Annalisa Barbieri addresses a personal problem sent in by a reader. If you would like advice from Annalisa, please send your problem to [email protected]. Annalisa regrets she cannot enter into personal correspondence. Submissions are subject to our terms and conditions. The latest series of Annalisa’s podcast is available here.
